IDF finally admits it bombed its own hostages to death. And of course they did.

Tamir Nimrodi - whose remains were returned - was bombed to death by Israel - as were all of the hostages that were killed in captivity. Israel always knew their bombs would kill them.

This work only survives if we face the truth together.

You won’t see any of this in the mainstream news, but it’s a huge deal in Israel today. Their own media is even more honest about the situation than our own. I refuse to be silent — and I need you with me. Please click here to become a member today. Your subscription keeps our Gaza reporting free for the world to read.

What the family and the army are now saying

The body of IDF Staff Sgt. Tamir Nimrodi, 18, was returned to Israel this week. His parents did not receive their son back alive — and the cause of death is the wound no parent can bear: forensic tests indicate Tamir was killed by Israeli airstrikes while he was a hostage.

The Hostages and Missing Families Forum issued a statement in Hebrew: Tamir “was abducted alive from his base and killed in an IDF airstrike while in captivity.” Drop Site News translated and reported the same. Israeli activist Alon-Lee Green put it plainly:

“Another hostage came back in a coffin because the IDF bombed him.”

Even Ynet, a Zionist outlet, confirms the core finding. Citing military sources and the Abu Kabir Institute of Forensic Medicine, Ynet reports the IDF’s “high-probability assessment” that Tamir — abducted from the Gaza DCL base on Oct. 7 along with Sgt. Ron Sherman, Cpl. Nik Beizer, and Elia Toledano — was “very likely” killed on Oct. 9, 2023 in an Israeli strike alongside all of his colleagues.

Read that again: an Israeli hostage, killed by an Israeli strike while in captivity.

So, it’s clear that Israel killed all 4 of these IDF soldiers in their bombing. Because, ummmm, that’s how bombs work. That’s how bombing an entire community until it is dust and rubble works.

When you drop tens of thousands of bombs on a place, you kill everyone and everything - cats, dogs, mothers, fathers - and hostages. It’s what bombs do.

---

Why this matters beyond one unbearable loss

From the first days of this genocide, Israel’s political and military leadership told the world they were bombing to save the hostages. Families pleaded for restraint; many begged the government to prioritize negotiations. They were mocked, ignored, or worse — told that “unimaginable force” was the only language Hamas understood.

Tamir’s death exposes the fatal arithmetic of that policy: bombing the places where hostages are held kills hostages.

You can’t rescue people by incinerating the rooms they’re in.

This is not the first time we have heard variations of the same tragedy. Throughout the war, multiple hostages — Israeli and foreign — have been reported killed by Israeli fire during raids, tank fire, or airstrikes. Each time, leaders say “fog of war.” But “fog” is not a policy. Choosing to drop munitions on densely populated areas known to contain hostages is a policy. It predictably produces coffins.

---

Objection & Answer

Objection: Hamas held him; they are responsible for anything that happened to hostages.
Answer: Hamas bears responsibility for abduction and captivity. But international law does not allow you to bomb hostages and call it rescue. The Hostage Families Forum and the IDF’s own forensic assessment identify IDF strikes as the cause of death. That demands accountability, not deflection.

Objection: It’s tragic but unavoidable — fog of war.
Answer: Avoidable is the point. When leadership chooses air power over negotiation, chooses “pressure” over protection, the foreseeable outcome is dead hostages. Family after family warned of this. They were right.

Objection: The IDF says “very likely,” not 100 percent.
Answer: The army cites location of the bodies, operational and intelligence analyses, and pathology. The Hostages Forum calls it outright. If there is any uncertainty, it strengthens the case for a transparent, independent investigation— not for silence.

---

What accountability must look like

• Independent investigation with public findings: the strike package, target vetting, collateral-damage estimates, and what was known about hostage location at the time.

• Immediate policy change: no use of explosive weapons in populated areas where hostages are likely present; ROE and targeting rules that treat every suspected hostage site as a no-strike zone.

• Full transparency to families: real-time briefings on constraints and red lines, not PR.

• Cease the lie that air power is a rescue plan. It is not. Negotiation freed the living; bombs killed the captive.

---

This truth costs courage.

That’s the price of journalism free from governments and propaganda. Please become a member so we can keep telling the truth while the powerful try to bury it.

Love and appreciate each of you.
Your friend and brother,
Shaun

Don’t Stop Here: Here are 3 FREE articles for you…